As a plastic surgeon deeply immersed in facial rejuvenation techniques, I’ve seen trends come and go, but the hype around the deep plane facelift deserves a critical evaluation.
What Is A Deep Plane Facelift?
“Deep plane facelifts” target the layers beneath the SMAS (Superficial Muscular Aponeurotic System), going deeper to manipulate the facial muscles and fat. Surgeons who advocate for this method argue that it provides a more comprehensive, longer-lasting lift. The procedure involves incisions similar to a regular facelift, but the surgeon works under the SMAS layer, repositioning the deeper tissues for a superior lift.
But when we examine the deep plane facelift surgical approach, we uncover several concerns:
- Complexity and Risks: The invasive nature of manipulating deeper facial structures increases the risk of complications like nerve damage and hematoma, leading to longer recovery times and a higher potential for adverse outcomes.
- Longer Procedure: Deep plane facelifts require more anesthesia time, which poses greater risks.
- More Expensive: Many plastic surgeons charge a premium for deep plane facelifts, ranging from $15,000 to $38,000, depending on the practice.
- Outdated Methodology: Despite some refinements, the deep plane facelift lacks the continual innovation seen in less invasive methods. It often falls behind in adopting the technological advances that have revolutionized regular facelifts.
- Recovery and Downtime: Patients must prepare for extended recovery, often requiring additional time off from their daily activities and work.
Despite the claims of some plastic surgeons, deep plane facelifts often don’t provide enough additional benefit to justify the increased risks and extended downtime. While they may be suitable for certain cases with severe sagging, the enhanced safety profile, shorter recovery, and impressive results of regular facelifts make them the preferable choice for most patients.
Why We Prefer Regular Facelifts
In contrast, the regular superficial musculoaponeurotic system (SMAS) plication facelift technique typically yields better results with fewer risks. During this procedure, we focus on tightening the SMAS layer, which provides a supportive lift to the face while removing excess skin to create a natural, rejuvenated appearance. One study concluded that SMAS plication face-lifts scored higher than deep-plane face-lifts in terms of aesthetic results for patients younger than 70.
By comparison, regular facelifts pose several benefits:
- Less Invasive: Regular facelifts offer substantial results without delving into the deeper, more risky facial structures. This approach reduces the chances of nerve damage and other serious complications.
- Refined and Personalized: Modern techniques allow surgeons to tailor the procedure to each patient’s unique facial structure, providing a customized, natural look rather than a one-size-fits-all solution.
- Quicker Recovery: Patients generally enjoy a quicker, more comfortable recovery, making the regular facelift a more convenient and less disruptive option.
- Innovative Techniques: Regular facelifts benefit from advancements in technology and technique, ensuring they remain at the forefront of cosmetic surgery.
Two Common Facelift Techniques
SMAS plication involves lifting the SMAS layer, elevating it to a higher and more youthful position, and folding it onto itself to augment the cheekbones and midface. We lift and reposition facial tissues through a small incision in front of the ear to reduce sagging and create a firmer, more toned appearance. It effectively tightens the SMAS without cutting it, reducing the risk of nerve damage. SMAS plication can provide significant results in the midface and cheek areas, leading to a rejuvenated look. This technique is less invasive than other methods and is often used in mini-lifts or patients with less severe facial sagging.
SMAS resection or SMAS flap creation, on the other hand, refers to a range of techniques that alter the SMAS layer more extensively. It includes cutting and lifting or otherwise repositioning the SMAS. Compared to SMAS plication, the SMASectomy is a more aggressive technique that involves removing a portion of the SMAS and then suturing the edges together. This can provide more dramatic results but comes with a higher risk of nerve injury or other complications.
Addressing the Hype Around Deep Plane Facelifts
Despite the claims of some proponents, deep plane facelifts often don’t provide enough additional benefit to justify the increased risks and extended downtime. Regular facelifts provide a safer, less invasive alternative, offering beautiful, natural-looking results with a more manageable recovery. As we continue to innovate in the field of cosmetic surgery, the focus should always remain on providing safe, effective, and personalized options to those seeking facial rejuvenation.
Understanding Patient Goals and Expectations
When considering a facelift, aligning surgical approaches with your goals and expectations is imperative. A thorough consultation is more than a preliminary step; it’s a foundational process where we, as surgeons, understand the patient’s vision for their rejuvenation journey. Whether a patient is leaning toward a mini lift, facelift, and/or fat grafting, we must consider factors like age, skin condition, lifestyle, and the extent of aging signs. In these detailed discussions, we often find regular facelifts align more closely with patient expectations of a natural, refreshed look with minimized risks and downtime.
As practitioners, we are responsible for setting realistic expectations ensuring patients are fully informed about each technique’s potential benefits and limitations. Our commitment is not just to the technical success of the procedure but to the satisfaction and well-being of our patients, guiding them to make decisions that will bring them confidence and happiness in the long run.
The Future of Facial Rejuvenation
The landscape of facial rejuvenation is continually evolving, with new technologies and techniques on the horizon that promise to redefine the standards of beauty and anti-aging treatments. As we look forward, we see a trend toward procedures that offer effective results with less invasiveness and reduced recovery times. Innovations in laser technology, ultrasound, and non-surgical skin tightening methods are already making waves, providing patients with more options to combat the signs of aging without the need for traditional surgery.
Additionally, breakthroughs in regenerative medicine, such as stem cell therapies and advanced biocompatible materials, can further revolutionize facial rejuvenation. These advancements aim to improve aesthetic outcomes and enhance the healing process and overall patient experience.
As plastic surgeons, we’re not just witnesses to these changes; we’re active participants, continually learning and adapting to ensure we provide our patients with the safest, most effective, and most promising options. The future of facial rejuvenation is bright, and our mission is to bring the best of these innovations to those we serve, helping them look and feel their best.
Book a Plastic Surgery Consultation in Arizona
Our qualified board-certified plastic surgeons at Plastic Surgeons of Northern Arizona would love to meet you to discuss your goals and treatment options. Book a consultation in Flagstaff, Sedona, Cottonwood, Prescott Valley, or Kingman today.